The surprising results of the recent midterm elections have raised the very real possibility of a recalibration of US-Israel relations — and a new set of challenges for AIPAC and other organizations advocating to maintain and strengthen these relations. Thankfully, AIPAC will always be AIPAC and will continue effectively to lobby pro-Israel members of Congress to remain steadfast in their support, and, hopefully, to win over newer members of Congress whose support for Israel is not yet a foregone conclusion.
Apart from the most obvious challenge — the plainly antizionist rhetoric of soon to be first-term Senator Abdul El-Sayed and a handful of equally antagonistic newly elected members of the House — the less obvious but perhaps even more important challenge will be to insure the support of those members of Congress who are pro-Israel but openly critical of certain Israeli policies — notably Senator Jon Ossoff from Georgia and our own Senator Elissa Slotkin — and especially the policies and actions of the Netanyahu government in Gaza and in the West Bank.
Winning over these members of Congress, who include most of the newly elected Democrats in the House, requires a more nuanced touch that, at once, recognizes unambivalently the legitimate right of the State of Israel to exist as a Jewish State — this must always be non-negotiable — while also acknowledging and being able to criticize problematic policies and actions, particularly those of extreme Israeli leaders such as Itamar Ben-Gvir and Bezalel Smotrich, and violent mitnachalim. All of this suggests an opportunity for J Street to re-assert itself as an impactful player in the complex world of Israel advocacy.
Founded in 2007 by Jeremy Ben-Ami as an alternative to AIPAC, J Street's mission combined a full-throated support for the Jewish People's right to a national home of their own and its right "to defend itself in accordance with US and International Law;" while also recognizing the need to negotiate a resolution to the conflict with the Palestinians and to end the occupation of the West Bank and Gaza. At the time, these two pillars resonated with many (perhaps most) American Jews and with many Israelis as well. It appeared at the time that J Street would be a useful counterpoint to AIPAC's dominant voice that, very much in the long Jewish traditional of the mutual benefit of contrary points of view, would maximize the impact of the American Jewish Community's advocacy for Israel.
At some point, perhaps a decade ago, J Street's two-pronged mission became muddled: criticism of the Netanyahu government intensified while insistence on State of Israel's right to exist quieted to little more than a pro forma soundbite and was relegated to the margins of the organization's rhetoric and advocacy. Not surprisingly, J Street was increasingly overshadowed by the larger, better funded, and more well-established AIPAC, and also drowned out by the ever louder, reflexive shrieking of the emerging alphabet soup of antizionism — JVP, SJP, and BDS — even more as the boundary between J Street's outlook and those of these other organizations blurred. As a result, J Street's real impact as an advocate of the State of Israel declined.
To be sure, this decline resulted, in part, from President Trump's unmitigated support for Israel, animated largely by a need to win and retain the support of Christian Evangelicals in order to ensure the electoral support of a dozen or more southern states; from his close partnership with Netanyahu, and from the fact that, even at the beginning of the 2020s, a substantial majority of Republican and Democrat congressmen alike still viewed support for the State of Israel — at the very least, military aid and strategic cooperation — as a given. The expectation that a negotiated settlement between Israel and the Palestinians presumed Israel "returning to the 1967 borders" (a point included even in Hamas' 1987 Charter) presupposed the continued existence of the State of Israel as a Jewish State. Increasingly since October 7, this focus has shifted to the legitimacy of the State of Israel itself.
This is the new reality of the US-Israel relationship that Israelis and American Jews now face. The pressing need to engage this new reality — coupled with the prospect of a post-Netanyahu government in Israel and a possible beginning of the end of Trumpism here — has opened a window of opportunity for J Street to assert a greater role in navigating this new landscape. This depends, on course, on whether or not J Street is willing and able to return to its original twin mission: advocating vigorously on behalf of the legitimacy of the State of Israel to exist as the Jewish State, and using this legitimacy as a necessary point of departure for any and all criticism of Israeli politics, politicians, and policies.
Moreover, defending the right of the State of Israel to exist as a Jewish state no longer means simply paying lip service to Israel's legitimacy. Rather it now means organizations such as J Street (and AIPAC) must actively engage with and refute the claims against Zionism and the State of Israel that, once the invention of erstwhile Soviet antizionist propagandists, have now permeated the ranks of American politics and academia and are eroding the sensible and once seemingly unassailable consensus regarding Israel's existence. J Street's emphasis on a balanced and nuanced perspective will enable the organization to spearhead the difficult effort to teach and convince members of Congress and others making vital decisions about US-Israel relations that these are false claims designed to demonize the Jewish State and exonerate its adversaries for any consequences.
For J Street, this means emphatically redrawing the once clear boundary between its balanced perspective on Israel and Zionism and those organizations that try to mask their unmeasured contempt for Israel and Zionism by calling it criticism of a government; and not settle for echoing these organizations' lack of intellectual acumen and curiosity. To this end, J Street must untether itself from intellectuals and self-styled experts — whom J Street has relied on in the past — whose otherwise keen ability to think critically and historically has increasingly been impeded by a blind spot when it comes to Zionism and the State of Israel, and whose approach to the Palestinians is hopelessly one-sided and dated; and rely instead on more cutting edge and relevant perspectives of intellectuals with a more rigorous understanding of past and present (thankfully there is no shortage); notably Haviv Rettig Gur, Micah Goodman, Einat Wilf, Hen Mazzig, Yossi Klein Halevi.
In short, in this difficult moment of transition, J Street has a real opportunity to lead. I hope they seize it.
Comments
Sign in or become a Nu?Detroit member to join the conversation.
Just enter your email below to get a log in link.