Jewish leadership is a funny thing. One day, someone asks you to go to an event or a meeting or join a board. For me, that happened when I was 26. If, like me, you say yes despite your reservations, suddenly you are a Jewish leader. You have joined the institutional Jewish world.

You start going to board meetings. And conferences. Maybe an international trip? You get invited to join a leadership fellowship. And then another.

For the last 20 years, I’ve moved through the institutional Jewish world. I’ve given my time because I love my community deeply. I love my faith deeply.

And there were always parts of me that didn’t quite fit in that world. I shoved those parts down, letting bits and pieces out when I felt safe enough to do so, or when my anger or sadness at the world overwhelmed me. As I got older and more secure, more of those pieces came out. I’d love to pretend this was bravery. Mostly, I was tired. It was exhausting to walk through the institutional Jewish world as only part of myself.

Over the last three months, I ventured into electoral politics in a way I’d never imagined and had never wanted to. I joined Michigan Jews for Democracy, a grassroots group of volunteers working to elect Abdul El-Sayed. The group was made up entirely of progressives … and me. And for anyone who thinks I’m a progressive, I suggest you grab a cup of coffee with an actual progressive.

I never would have joined the progressive group if Michigan Jews Against Extremism, the pro-Rogers group, hadn’t gone public. I was upset by the narrative that all Jews (or all good Jews) were supporting Mike Rogers. I wasn’t. So off we went.

In three months, we gathered more than 1,000 signatures, drew coverage from The New York Times and seemingly every Jewish publication imaginable, and hosted four house parties where I moderated conversations between elected officials and Jewish voters. Through our essays and videos and signatures, we were trying to tell other Jews that they weren’t alone. I spent a lot of my time trying to translate between progressives and moderates in our community. We can be saying the same thing and still sound like we’re speaking entirely different languages.

A friend and fellow Jewish leader who voted for Rogers sent me a message during the campaign.

Just be careful as you are truly a wonderful person and the whole community is watching what you are doing. I don’t want the respect for you dwindled over this smooth-talking, disingenuous person.

That message, sent with genuine sincerity, brought to the surface something that had been simmering in me for 20 years. I keep being told that the larger world wants me to hide myself. To be less Jewish. To be less me. And yet I’ve been my very Jewish self in Christian spaces and Muslim spaces and Hindu spaces. I’ve traveled the world. I’ve taught on university campuses. I’ve felt free to be openly Jewish in all of those places.

It was in the institutional Jewish world that I felt the need to hold back. I held back my concern for Palestinians. I held back my criticism of the Israeli government. I held back what I thought about settler violence and the settlement project itself.

I had been openly Jewish everywhere I went. And for years, I’d hidden parts of myself from the Jewish community. The community I’d spent 20 years showing up for. The community I love.

I don’t know how many people were watching me during the election, and I doubt many are watching me now. Still, I have one promise and one ask. I promise to be as open about my Judaism and my Zionism as I’ve always been, wherever I go.

And I ask you to make room for my whole Shabbat-loving, pro-Palestinian, settlement-rejecting, peace-seeking Zionist Jewish self in the institutions where we lead together.

I believe in equal rights for Palestinians and Israelis, and I want to be able to say that as plainly in those rooms as I do anywhere else.

If we want people in our community to trust that they can say what they really think and still belong, those of us who lead have to be willing to go first. And when someone tells us something we’d rather not hear, we have to give them the room we’ve asked for ourselves.

I think that’s where repair begins.